Commenting late to say yeah it feels extra disappointing because Dean experiencing being Death in an episode sounded like a really cool premise, and it was so cliched to just make it about him not wanting to reap a sick girl in hospital. I mean Dean knew it was a challenge for him, did he really think that he wouldn't have to reap any kids??? You'd think Dean of all people could face the reality of death not always happenng to those that deserve it

The ending was a great cliffhanger though. I liked the opening with Dean too, it was just what they actually did with the premise that was so cliched